"Whiter than White" : How Manchester City Council
Launders Ratepayer's Money to the Labour Party's Coffers

40 comments:

Croydonian said...

Thanks for the kudos Guido, but it was the Pope's Underpants who kicked the whole thing off.

Anonymous said...

Was it a cash donation or was it the free parking permits they give to every MP?

Guido Fawkes said...

You are thinking of BAA plc. This was cash from the Manchester Airport plc which is owned by Manchester's Labour controlled local government.

Anonymous said...

There is just one question to be answered here before I am wholly convinced that some sort of corrupt practice has been going on:

During the same period that 175 grand plus change was donated to Labour, did any money go to other political parties? If so how much and to whom?

On a slightly related point. At times when the City Council has been controlled by any other party (if ever) has money been "donated" by the airport company to the other party in power.

It might also be interesting to look at other council owned businesses. Luton Airort is a municipal airport isn't it? Anyone got a copy of their accounts?

RM

Anonymous said...

Isn't Doncaster Racecourse owned by the local coucil. I wonder what they hand out.

Rev Paul Martin said...

This is corruption - pure and simple!. If it has been done by other local authorities for other political parties, then they are also guitly of corruption.

Is there not a case for a surcharge to be levied for repayment of these moneys by the directors responsible?

Croydonian said...

The post I've made on my blog doesn't seem to be showing up, so I'll try here:

Were the board of the company councillors or officials? What happened to the remaining £71 000? Why wasn't this front page news for weeks? What were the board thinking that they thought that they could do this?

Anonymous said...

Been going on for years: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/kenyon_confronts/3208068.stm

There are ten councils who make up MAG - one of them is Lib Dem and one is Tory - the rest are Labour; 55% is owned my Manchester City Council and the other hold 5% each. MAG also ownes Bournemouth International Airport, Nottingham East Midlands Airport, and Humberside International Airport - it'd be interesting to see how much those give to the Labour party.

Anonymous said...

Update on Luton Airport.

Owned by Luton Borough Council but operated by a company called TBI plc who also operate Cardiff and Belfast Airports.

Accessing company reports from work is taking too long. I'll do it with broadband from home tonight. This being so I can't say whether they have been giving money to anyone.

One interesting factet has been found though: a certain Margaret McDonagh (43), Baroness of that ilk and formerly the youngest ever GenSec of the Labour Party (1998 - 2001) sits on the board as a non-executive director.

At least I know what I'm going to be doing this easter weekend - burning up my broadband ration digging into TI and Baroness McD.

Toodle pip

RM

Croydonian said...

Can't see anything in TBI's annual report: http://www.tbiplc.co.uk/reportsAcc/AnnualReport.pdf

Croydonian said...

There's more. Birminhgam International Airport gave £9,500 in 2003, and it appears that it is 49% owned by sundry councils in the West Midlands. Can't see any donations to the Tories by airports.

I think this one has legs, doesn't it?

Anonymous said...

Manchester Airport Group's Annual Report & Accounts 2004/05 states:

'Charitable donations made by the Group and its subsidiaries during the year totalled £197,000 (2004: £203,000). The donations
were all made to recognised local charities for a variety of purposes. It is the Group’s policy not to make contributions to political
parties.'

Anonymous said...

Thanks Croydonian,

Still interesting that Margaret McDonagh, responsible for and fired because of labour's London Mayoral Election clusterfuck resurfaces a couple of years later as non-exec director of a company deeply involved in PPI initiatives with various municipal airports and is promptly made a baroness.

According to www.answers.com both she and her sister (Siobhan) who is an MP are both so Blairite it's untrue.

RM

Anonymous said...

PuP

They certainly did from 01 to 02

from

www.greenparty.org.uk/files/ reports/2003/airport%20donations%201.htm - 23k -


2.1 Manchester Airport plc has made in-kind donations that would probably pay for Labour’s local election campaign throughout the North West region. Between February 2001 and October 2002 donations from Manchester airport to Labour totalled £271,723.02. Manchester airport is now Labour's 21st biggest donor.

So it seems they used to but they don't now

All clear now?

Anonymous said...

These are the issues you'd expect Conservative Councillors in Manchester to be harping on about.

Instead scraggy-faced Joan Howarth was busy busy waxing lyrical on Channel 4 about how she doesn't want an ethnic minority councillor/MP where she lives.

Is it any wonder we've lost 3 General Elections in a row ?

Anonymous said...

****Mr Cameron said of Mrs Howarth's remarks: "She is in the wrong party She is unrepresentative of the modern Conservative party. At the last election we had more candidates from the black and ethnic minority communities than any other party."***

Anyone know where to find if this can possibly be true?

Anonymous said...

Many local people / opposition politicians / journos have tried to find out about the peculiar stuff that goes on in the business interests of Manchester City Council - which are more than you might imagine a council would have.

Naturally, no evidence has ever come to light. This might be because they're whiter than white of course, and that we're just cynical fools.

Croydonian said...

Re Gerrymander

If you have a lot of time, you could always work your way through the results on the BBC's Vote 2005 website, although without photos one would have to rely on surnames as an indicator, I fear. I wonder if DC is including Jewish people, who seem to have been airbrushed out of the ethnic minority definition.

Anonymous said...

http://www.cre.gov.uk/Default.aspx.LocID-0hgnew06c.RefLocID-0hg00900c008.Lang-EN.htm

At the risk of answering my own question it seems its true 41 Con 40 LD 32 Lab ethnic minority candidates

Rigger Mortice said...

careful with all ethnic questions/assertions.The reality is that at the last GE we have 345 or so paper candidates and having seen the quality of some....

On the Joan Howarth thing,if all she said was that an ethnic candidate wouldn't work in her ward then to put it simply she could be right.I have lived in my hometown all my life and know the area well.There are certain areas where you would sensibly stand different ethnicities and others where you wouldn't,purely on the grounds that they won't get in.For DC to turn on her and say she's in the wrong party is a bit rich coming from someone who is.

Back to topic,I wonder if manchester labour party bother fundraising?

Anonymous said...

They're at it in Scotland this very day:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/4899706.stm

Anonymous said...

RM
Your barking the wrong tree with TBI
"TBI, the owner of Cardiff, Luton, Belfast and other airports, has accepted a £551m takeover bid from Abertis of Spain." Nov 2004
It was interesting to watch their cuddling up to New Labour in recent years but before that the Thomas brothers (major drivers/shareholders) were very Supportive of the ..ahem Conservative Party

Anonymous said...

Yeah, Ulsterman, I was beginning to suspect that. Sadly. It would have been nice to have established a pattern of behaviour. Guess I'll be surfing for inappropriate pictures instead of digging for political dirt this easter weekend.

Still, Lady McDonagh's rapid rise from Labour hack to non-exec director of a PPI company does seem a little odd. Especially as peerage seems to have been part of the whole process.

RM

Anonymous said...

On the Joan Howarth thing,if all she said was that an ethnic candidate wouldn't work in her ward then to put it simply she could be right.

What a load of crappy socialist thinking right there.
Scraggy-Face Howarth, clearly doesn't know the difference between ethnic minority, immigrant, asylum-seeker or tourist. Her comment would only make sense if she was talking about the last three, not the first. (yes, i know it is possible to be all of the above).

It was a slur on working-class people in general and the woman clearly has a low-IQ.

Why would a black nurse, who has lived in her ward for 20-odd years, gone to a local nursing school and who works at the local hospital not be able to stand for councillor? Because people wouldn't like the colour of his/her face? You cannot know that until after they vote.

Howarth speaks only for herself and expresses only her views. She needs to leave my party!

Anonymous said...

Isn't Preston one of the characters in Wallace and Gromit?

Anonymous said...

Why is Manchester Airport owned by Manchester City Council? It's not actually in Manchester. It is partly in Lib Dem Stockport and partly in Tory Cheshire.

simon said...

Manchester council also own Eastlands, the home ground of Manchester City FC, who have a 1000 year lease on a peppercorn rent. I think the deal was that in return, the council got City's old ground in Moss Side to redevelop. It might be worth someone un picking that little lot

Cicero said...

Have not had a decent Poulson scandal in ages...

Anonymous said...

Slightly off topic...

Nirex the "state owned" nuclear waste-management organisation has also donated £11k to keep the Labour party sweet (according to their Director's Report for 2005). Up from 8.5k in 2004...

Can't think why... is their future in doubt?

simon said...

Also of interest may be the donation made to Labour by Richard Desmond which preceded the OFT and Steven Byers declaring him a 'fit and proper person' to run a national newspaper. I think the donation was in kind (ad space) rather than cash and the sated value was £100k.

Anonymous said...

Squid,

Didn't City get the ground because there was nothing to do with it after the Commonwealth Games?

Anonymous said...

DFL

Nah, his stuff's crap; take it from a connosewer.

RM

Anonymous said...

Actually Ringway is in City council land. Also because manchester Council when tory back in the thirties built it

Anonymous said...

If there is a law that has been broken then it will relate to the prohibition of the use of public money for party political purposes. But then again that'll be why it was routed through a, technically, private company, the Manchester Airports Group. Whether or not the law has actually been broken this stinks to high heaven.

Serf said...

Just goes to show that the airport should be privatised.

Anonymous said...

manchester airport is not owned by manchester council

It's owned by the 10 local authorites of greater manchester - which include libdem stockport, Oldham which was libdem until last time round and a number of NOCs

All parties are all happy to fund the lobbying of labour as they're in government and they've been very helpful in allowing Manchester Airport to expand its operations

whether that's right or wrong is another issue

Anonymous said...

According to my reading of the Manchester City Council accounts (PDF link) , the Council received a dividend of £9m from its shareholding in Manchester Airport Group (and also received rent and loan repayments). So where are the subsidies that form the second link in the chain?

Anonymous said...

As Steve says above, all 10 Greater Manchester Councils have holdings in MAG, but Manchester City Council by far the largest share.

Manchester Labour have also received some substantial donations - £4000 from Crosby Homes and £5000 from Ask Property Development to Manchester Central CLP in 2004... and that's before you even get started on the trade union donations...

Anonymous said...

A quick search of the electoral commission's register of donations reveals that the National Labour Party received £30000 from "Manchester Airport Group" on each of two separate occasions in 2002 - a total of £60000. Obviously this does not include pre-2001 donations.

Less well reported is the £6748.02 (odd number, I know) donation made by "Manchester Airport PLC" to the Liberal Democrat Federal Party in August 2001...

Paul Leake said...

I think I read some years ago that MAG made donations in proportion to the controlling parties of their 'member' authorities. Which would explain the money for the LibDems.