Prescott & Anschutz - Yard Gets Formal Complaint Under 1916 Prevention of Corruption Acts
48
comments:
Anonymous
said...
It all seems a bit pointles really. They will just get Lord Hutton to hold an inquiry and Tony any friends will be whiter than white!
July 17, 2006 at 11:41 AM
Anonymous
said...
On the road to accountable government ! This is clearly the way to bring the Smoke & Mirrors boys to heel............it is time to clean the Augean Stables
one "ethics is a county next to kent" two jags three shags four legs good (two legs better) five...?,well, five shags six croquet hoops seven meetings with Anschutz eight years of council tax arrears nine weeks as boss each summer ...and a ten gallon hat (undeclared)
July 17, 2006 at 11:45 AM
Anonymous
said...
Sorry to be unduly serious but there are concerns about the effect of the HRA on the burden of proof in corruption cases and on the application to a Secretary of State of said laws BUT NuLab helpfully extended the application of the 1916 act through the 2001 Anti-Terrorism Act to bring statutes in line with Common Law offences as in "For the purposes of any common law offence of bribery it is immaterial if the functions of the person who receives or is offered a reward have no connection with the United Kingdom and are carried out in a country or territory outside the United Kingdom."
So it'll be poetic justice for Prescott to be imprisoned as a result of his governments use of anti-terrorism to widen its powers.
I had heard, (can't remember where) that Norman Baker MP (Lid dem for Lewes) had already lodged a complaint against him uner that act.
July 17, 2006 at 12:12 PM
Anonymous
said...
Gordo's had a boy!
Awww.... bless.
July 17, 2006 at 12:14 PM
Anonymous
said...
benedict white
Quite so - reported in the Independent on 8th July - though this was a 'request to investigate' vs a 'complaint'
July 17, 2006 at 12:16 PM
Anonymous
said...
This could be marginally off-topic, but what news of Baroness Scotland's Washington trip to convince Dr. Rice or Congress to formalise reciprocal extradition arrangements, specifically the 2003 (Blunkett) Extradition Act. Could we then fast-track Philip Anschutz's extradition to Gatwick, to answer a charge of alleged bribery?
Many thanks Carlottavance. Interesting to see how bad news travels.
July 17, 2006 at 12:24 PM
Anonymous
said...
carlottavance New Zealand now has electricity,cars and all kinds of other things,even t.v. and the internet.It`s in the Southern Hemisphere......not on Mars.
July 17, 2006 at 12:24 PM
Anonymous
said...
"Gordo's had a boy"
I hope you mean that Mrs Gordo has been delivered of a male child (and not some deplorable piece of gossip which no-one could possibly believe).
July 17, 2006 at 12:24 PM
Anonymous
said...
The one-way extradition treaty only works UK --> US. Baroness Scotland headed off there to test it out. She bunged the Govt. a few quid and was given a whole country. If they can't extradite her back (she's now officially missing) then they will know its safe for the rest of the TB govt to claim sanctuary there.
July 17, 2006 at 12:26 PM
Anonymous
said...
rog said "Gordo's had a boy!"
Think you`ll find Tony just looked young for his age at the time rog
July 17, 2006 at 12:27 PM
Anonymous
said...
Moko, very true - a lovely country - I've enjoyed all 5 of my visits - the comment was aimed at how far reporting of NuLab sleaze has spread....rather than casting any nusturtiums in its direction....
July 17, 2006 at 12:31 PM
Anonymous
said...
Concerning the fragrant Tony, shouldn't that be "bitch-boy"?
I'm sure they'll all be popular if they ever have to do time.
July 17, 2006 at 12:33 PM
Anonymous
said...
12.26 Anonymous
You've got it all wrong:
A controversial US-UK extradition treaty would "threaten, intimidate, harass and persecute and terrorise Irish-American citizens", a legal expert will tell Congress this week
See here: http://tinyurl.com/fpgwd
bend over.....
July 17, 2006 at 12:35 PM
Anonymous
said...
And according to Iain Dale, Gordo has named his new male child, er "Gordon".
That is a bit peculiar, isn't it?
Gordon Brown number two at No. 11.
July 17, 2006 at 12:37 PM
Anonymous
said...
If George Bathurst's interpretation is correct, then probably over half the cabinet, junior ministers and labour donors are looking at prison terms. NuLabour's traditional get out of not keeping any records won't wash. This is huge.
July 17, 2006 at 12:49 PM
Anonymous
said...
Rog: It's a case of mini-Gord
With regard to the first comment in the thread, the Government can hardly ask Lord Whitewa- I mean Hutton to hold another Inquiry, since this would need to be a criminal inquiry by the police.
Yates of the Yard is already doing a superb job... looks like he might need a few extra officers on the job (not in the Prescott sense of the phrase)...
With reference to the Human Rights Act, ted, it might be a defence that Prescott's laywers could use. However, as it's never been tried before it's high risk and at best wouldn't put all the burden of proof back on the crown. Even if it did, there's enough evidence already in the public domain (i.e. Prescott's unravelling story about claiming not to have had discussed the dome etc) to give a high chance of conviction. I fully expect the police to be bringing charges within the week.
Perhaps Gordon's new baby will be the only nuLabour supporter not to be tainted by this.
July 17, 2006 at 1:05 PM
Anonymous
said...
And as the sun sinks slowly on NuLab the 'Chipolata Kid' wearing only a stetson, spurs and belt mounts his trusty steed 'Rosie' and rides off to a new begining..............
Is there DWP office in Hull?
July 17, 2006 at 1:08 PM
Anonymous
said...
Dear John, You have been sat too long here on your fat arse for any good you have been doing. Depart, I say, and let us have done with you. In the name of God, go! Regards, The United Kingdom.
July 17, 2006 at 1:14 PM
Anonymous
said...
Nice try, Mr Bathurst, but no cigar.
From "Points for Prosecutors", Section 2 PCA 1916 may be subject to challenge on the basis that it violates Article 6(2)of the Convention. The provision applies a presumption of corruption unless the contrary is proved in respect of payments to persons in public employment prosecuted under the 1889 or 1906 Acts. It may be argued that such a reverse onus provision infringes the right of the accused to be presumed innocent.
Which might provide us with the spectacle of Cherie Booth QC defending members of the government on the grounds that their rights under Article 6(2) of the EHCR were being denied, but for the following advice to the CPS,
In appropriate cases, prosecutors should consider the alternative offence of conspiracy under section 1 Criminal Law Act 1977, which will avoid use of the presumption – see R v Attorney General ex parte Rockall (2000) 1 WLR 882. Corruption in public office may also be prosecuted under common law (see R v Bowden (1996) 1 WLR 98; R v Whittaker(1914) 3 KB 128). Prosecutions under either section 1 or as a common law offence do not involve reliance upon the presumption in section 2 PCA 1916.
Sero, 'It may be argued' does not make it so (unless there is a precedent, which there isn't). Article 6(2) of the HRC says, 'Everyone charged with a criminal offence shall be presumed innocent until proved guilty according to law.' The 1916 Act makes it an offence for public officials to receive gifts from contractors, whether or not they are bribes. (The reason for this being that the two are so difficult to tell apart.)
In keeping with the HRC, therefore, Prescott should be charged in accordance with the law, bailed as appropriate and not sentenced before and if he is convicted.
It is not the police/CPS's role to make innovative interpretations of law, but the court's. The CPS uses this argument all the time in other cases. Their job is just to assess the liklihood of successful prosecution, which given the paper trail already made public, must be considered high even without using the 1916 Act.
The other legal routes you mention are not really appropriate here because the advice is refering to cases of lower public importance, where saving prosecution money is important, and where you can rely on the defendants not doing everything with such mafia style informality. Also even if the 1916 Act were to be suspended by a court at Cherie Blair's pleading, her client would still be facing prosecution under the 1906 Act, as they are not mutually exclusive.
The 1916 Act is compatible with the HRC, was designed for just this sort of case and makes Prescott's defence that bit trickier - and the case for the police bringing charges much stronger.
July 17, 2006 at 3:08 PM
Anonymous
said...
The CPS advice is exactly the sort of over-interpretation of the HRA that NuLab have been complaining about recently.
If reverse onus was incompatible with Human Rights law then the speed camera laws would all be illegal (because they assume the registered keeper is the speeder unless proved otherwise). Because our government fought very hard - and successfully - for this principle to be upheld, reverse onus is therefore compatible with EU law. We can't have one law for the little people and another for Government ministers.
Also reverse onus it not the same as a presumption of guilt; it just defines certain acts (e.g. taking gifts/owning a car) as equivalent to others (taking bribes/driving a car).
Finally, a reverst onus is not to be confused with a reverse anus, something which is very fashionable these days.
July 17, 2006 at 3:36 PM
Anonymous
said...
Surely the point, before we all go out and party, is:
"Mr Prescott must prove that he did not influence government thinking in order to avoid conviction."
Now what right-thinking Judge (or Jury) is ever going to believe that anyone, in government could possibly have their thinking influenced by John Prescott (unless they were female and JP made a grab for the groin)?
July 17, 2006 at 4:23 PM
Anonymous
said...
I'm fascinated by all the legal talk but let's get real. Does anyone really believe that any member of this government, elected or non-elected, or the labour party is going to be charged or convicted for any wromg doing. In spite of all the revalations as of yet there has not even been a resignation. This lot show nothing but contempt for the electorate and the law of the land and so far have completely got away with it. Sorry to put the dampers on it but my take is that in one years time they will all still be here and there will not be one charge or conviction, pending or otherwise. I hope I am wrong!
July 17, 2006 at 4:31 PM
Anonymous
said...
For anybody interested in what Sero said, the full text of Advice for Prosecutors is available here http://www.lslo.gov.uk/pdf/prosecutors.pdf (p39). On page 40 it says "The provision [the presumption of corruption] is compatible, or can be read compatibly with the Convention [the Human Rights Act]." Perhaps like too many others, Sero didn't bother reading the chapter beyond the first 2 paras.
July 17, 2006 at 4:35 PM
Anonymous
said...
jilted tony 4.38 The dear Caudillo died in office and of old age
July 17, 2006 at 5:00 PM
Anonymous
said...
It'll be interesting to see whether it's the Met or the CPS who don't press charges and complete our drift to a банановая республика - as president Putin will be joking at the next G* summit.
July 17, 2006 at 5:36 PM
Anonymous
said...
In the words of one Blair to another : you peel my банановая and I'll peel yours.
July 17, 2006 at 6:04 PM
Anonymous
said...
Ring ring ring
Blair: Hello hello hello
Blair: I've peeled your банановая now you peel mine.
Blair: I'm your Peeler.
click.
July 17, 2006 at 6:19 PM
Anonymous
said...
Nobody seems to have raised the point, will the mainstream meeja run with the story ? Clearly if the broadsheets give the story credibility, its harder for plod to disregard it out of hand. Just don't expect al-beeb to be leading the pack !
I can see the police investigation placing the papers to the CPS who will say there is insufficient evidence. But that Prescott will be charged with an offence undfer the Health and Safety Regulations for using an office desk for purposes other than for work and wearing cowboy boots in a workplace.
July 17, 2006 at 7:05 PM
Anonymous
said...
Nick Leamington Spa said...
"This could be marginally off-topic, but what news of Baroness Scotland's Washington trip to convince Dr. Rice or Congress to formalise reciprocal extradition arrangements"
Never going to happen. where DO you think Tony is planning to hide when it's all over...
July 17, 2006 at 8:05 PM
Anonymous
said...
What does банановая республика mean ?
July 17, 2006 at 8:16 PM
Anonymous
said...
банановая республика = banana republic
ps: "Things can only get better"
July 17, 2006 at 9:10 PM
Anonymous
said...
банановая республика=banana republic I imagine.
July 17, 2006 at 9:20 PM
Anonymous
said...
Anonymous 8:16 said... What does банановая республика mean ?
Banana Republic
July 17, 2006 at 9:23 PM
Anonymous
said...
GF - monitoring of comments isnt very productive - what is going on?
July 17, 2006 at 9:26 PM
Anonymous
said...
could it be that two jags and three shags will simply be known as an old lag !
July 17, 2006 at 10:40 PM
Anonymous
said...
A pity that the latest episode of The Arab-Israeli Conflict is taking up headline news. It makes it easier to ignore things such as this.
July 17, 2006 at 11:48 PM
Anonymous
said...
I love Banana Republic. They have the best chino skirts.
Speedjunky, traffic cams have already been found to presume guilt in at least one court of law (my friend was the judge) and their evidence tossed out, so don't rule anything out yet.
And I'm with nony 9:26. How many bananas do you need to make a fruit salad?
July 18, 2006 at 5:58 AM
Anonymous
said...
Pedant said..."The dear Caudillo died in office and of old age".
Not wishing to be pednatic, which one?
I can think of Juan Manuel de Rosas, Juan Facundo Quiroga, Antonio López de Santa Anna, José Gaspar Rodríguez de Francia, José Tadeo Monagas,Antonio Guzmán Blanco, Juan Vicente Gómez, Gabriel García Moreno, Rafael Trujillo and Francisco Franco, to name but ten.
48 comments:
It all seems a bit pointles really. They will just get Lord Hutton to hold an inquiry and Tony any friends will be whiter than white!
On the road to accountable government ! This is clearly the way to bring the Smoke & Mirrors boys to heel............it is time to clean the Augean Stables
one "ethics is a county next to kent"
two jags
three shags
four legs good (two legs better)
five...?,well, five shags
six croquet hoops
seven meetings with Anschutz
eight years of council tax arrears
nine weeks as boss each summer
...and a ten gallon hat (undeclared)
Sorry to be unduly serious but there are concerns about the effect of the HRA on the burden of proof in corruption cases and on the application to a Secretary of State of said laws BUT NuLab helpfully extended the application of the 1916 act through the 2001 Anti-Terrorism Act to bring statutes in line with Common Law offences as in "For the purposes of any common law offence of bribery it is immaterial if the functions of the person who receives or is offered a reward have no connection with the United Kingdom and are carried out in a country or territory outside the United Kingdom."
So it'll be poetic justice for Prescott to be imprisoned as a result of his governments use of anti-terrorism to widen its powers.
Bye Bye - Two shags!!!!
I had heard, (can't remember where) that Norman Baker MP (Lid dem for Lewes) had already lodged a complaint against him uner that act.
Gordo's had a boy!
Awww.... bless.
benedict white
Quite so - reported in the Independent on 8th July - though this was a 'request to investigate' vs a 'complaint'
This could be marginally off-topic, but what news of Baroness Scotland's Washington trip to convince Dr. Rice or Congress to formalise reciprocal extradition arrangements, specifically the 2003 (Blunkett) Extradition Act. Could we then fast-track Philip Anschutz's extradition to Gatwick, to answer a charge of alleged bribery?
....even got reported in New Zealand:
http://tinyurl.com/rcwn7
Many thanks Carlottavance. Interesting to see how bad news travels.
carlottavance New Zealand now has electricity,cars and all kinds of other things,even t.v. and the internet.It`s in the Southern Hemisphere......not on Mars.
"Gordo's had a boy"
I hope you mean that Mrs Gordo has been delivered of a male child (and not some deplorable piece of gossip which no-one could possibly believe).
The one-way extradition treaty only works UK --> US. Baroness Scotland headed off there to test it out. She bunged the Govt. a few quid and was given a whole country. If they can't extradite her back (she's now officially missing) then they will know its safe for the rest of the TB govt to claim sanctuary there.
rog said
"Gordo's had a boy!"
Think you`ll find Tony just looked young for his age at the time rog
Moko, very true - a lovely country - I've enjoyed all 5 of my visits - the comment was aimed at how far reporting of NuLab sleaze has spread....rather than casting any nusturtiums in its direction....
Concerning the fragrant Tony, shouldn't that be "bitch-boy"?
I'm sure they'll all be popular if they ever have to do time.
12.26 Anonymous
You've got it all wrong:
A controversial US-UK extradition treaty would "threaten, intimidate, harass and persecute and terrorise Irish-American citizens", a legal expert will tell Congress this week
See here: http://tinyurl.com/fpgwd
bend over.....
And according to Iain Dale, Gordo has named his new male child, er "Gordon".
That is a bit peculiar, isn't it?
Gordon Brown number two at No. 11.
If George Bathurst's interpretation is correct, then probably over half the cabinet, junior ministers and labour donors are looking at prison terms. NuLabour's traditional get out of not keeping any records won't wash. This is huge.
Rog: It's a case of mini-Gord
With regard to the first comment in the thread, the Government can hardly ask Lord Whitewa- I mean Hutton to hold another Inquiry, since this would need to be a criminal inquiry by the police.
Yates of the Yard is already doing a superb job... looks like he might need a few extra officers on the job (not in the Prescott sense of the phrase)...
With reference to the Human Rights Act, ted, it might be a defence that Prescott's laywers could use. However, as it's never been tried before it's high risk and at best wouldn't put all the burden of proof back on the crown. Even if it did, there's enough evidence already in the public domain (i.e. Prescott's unravelling story about claiming not to have had discussed the dome etc) to give a high chance of conviction. I fully expect the police to be bringing charges within the week.
Perhaps Gordon's new baby will be the only nuLabour supporter not to be tainted by this.
And as the sun sinks slowly on NuLab the 'Chipolata Kid' wearing only a stetson, spurs and belt mounts his trusty steed 'Rosie' and rides off to a new begining..............
Is there DWP office in Hull?
Dear John,
You have been sat too long here on your fat arse for any good you have been doing. Depart, I say, and let us have done with you. In the name of God, go!
Regards,
The United Kingdom.
Nice try, Mr Bathurst, but no cigar.
From "Points for Prosecutors",
Section 2 PCA 1916 may be subject to challenge on the basis that it violates Article 6(2)of the Convention. The provision applies a presumption of corruption unless the contrary is proved in respect of payments to persons in public employment prosecuted under the 1889 or 1906 Acts. It may be argued that such a reverse onus provision infringes the right of the accused to be presumed innocent.
Which might provide us with the spectacle of Cherie Booth QC defending members of the government on the grounds that their rights under Article 6(2) of the EHCR were being denied, but for the following advice to the CPS,
In appropriate cases, prosecutors should consider the alternative offence of conspiracy under section 1 Criminal Law Act 1977, which will avoid use of the presumption – see R v Attorney General ex parte Rockall (2000) 1 WLR 882. Corruption in public office may also be prosecuted under common law (see R v Bowden
(1996) 1 WLR 98; R v Whittaker(1914) 3 KB 128). Prosecutions under either section 1 or as a common law offence do not involve reliance upon the presumption in section 2 PCA 1916.
Follow The Money
Appiles to any contract? PFI anyone?
"...infringes the right of the accused to be presumed innocent..."
Rather a lot of people in Belmarsh and other places to whom that might apply, especially when they haven't actually been formally accused.
Sero, 'It may be argued' does not make it so (unless there is a precedent, which there isn't). Article 6(2) of the HRC says, 'Everyone charged with a criminal offence shall be presumed innocent until proved guilty according to law.' The 1916 Act makes it an offence for public officials to receive gifts from contractors, whether or not they are bribes. (The reason for this being that the two are so difficult to tell apart.)
In keeping with the HRC, therefore, Prescott should be charged in accordance with the law, bailed as appropriate and not sentenced before and if he is convicted.
It is not the police/CPS's role to make innovative interpretations of law, but the court's. The CPS uses this argument all the time in other cases. Their job is just to assess the liklihood of successful prosecution, which given the paper trail already made public, must be considered high even without using the 1916 Act.
The other legal routes you mention are not really appropriate here because the advice is refering to cases of lower public importance, where saving prosecution money is important, and where you can rely on the defendants not doing everything with such mafia style informality. Also even if the 1916 Act were to be suspended by a court at Cherie Blair's pleading, her client would still be facing prosecution under the 1906 Act, as they are not mutually exclusive.
The 1916 Act is compatible with the HRC, was designed for just this sort of case and makes Prescott's defence that bit trickier - and the case for the police bringing charges much stronger.
The CPS advice is exactly the sort of over-interpretation of the HRA that NuLab have been complaining about recently.
If reverse onus was incompatible with Human Rights law then the speed camera laws would all be illegal (because they assume the registered keeper is the speeder unless proved otherwise). Because our government fought very hard - and successfully - for this principle to be upheld, reverse onus is therefore compatible with EU law. We can't have one law for the little people and another for Government ministers.
Also reverse onus it not the same as a presumption of guilt; it just defines certain acts (e.g. taking gifts/owning a car) as equivalent to others (taking bribes/driving a car).
Finally, a reverst onus is not to be confused with a reverse anus, something which is very fashionable these days.
Surely the point, before we all go out and party, is:
"Mr Prescott must prove that he did not influence government thinking in order to avoid conviction."
Now what right-thinking Judge (or Jury) is ever going to believe that anyone, in government could possibly have their thinking influenced by John Prescott (unless they were female and JP made a grab for the groin)?
I'm fascinated by all the legal talk but let's get real. Does anyone really believe that any member of this government, elected or non-elected, or the labour party is going to be charged or convicted for any wromg doing.
In spite of all the revalations as of yet there has not even been a resignation. This lot show nothing but contempt for the electorate and the law of the land and so far have completely got away with it.
Sorry to put the dampers on it but my take is that in one years time they will all still be here and there will not be one charge or conviction, pending or otherwise.
I hope I am wrong!
For anybody interested in what Sero said, the full text of Advice for Prosecutors is available here http://www.lslo.gov.uk/pdf/prosecutors.pdf (p39). On page 40 it says
"The provision [the presumption of corruption] is compatible, or can be read compatibly with the Convention [the Human Rights Act]." Perhaps like too many others, Sero didn't bother reading the chapter beyond the first 2 paras.
jilted tony
4.38
The dear Caudillo died in office and of old age
It'll be interesting to see whether it's the Met or the CPS who don't press charges and complete our drift to a банановая республика - as president Putin will be joking at the next G* summit.
In the words of one Blair to another : you peel my банановая and I'll peel yours.
Ring ring ring
Blair: Hello hello hello
Blair: I've peeled your банановая now you peel mine.
Blair: I'm your Peeler.
click.
Nobody seems to have raised the point, will the mainstream meeja run with the story ?
Clearly if the broadsheets give the story credibility, its harder for plod to disregard it out of hand. Just don't expect al-beeb to be leading the pack !
I can see the police investigation placing the papers to the CPS who will say there is insufficient evidence. But that Prescott will be charged with an offence undfer the Health and Safety Regulations for using an office desk for purposes other than for work and wearing cowboy boots in a workplace.
Nick Leamington Spa said...
"This could be marginally off-topic, but what news of Baroness Scotland's Washington trip to convince Dr. Rice or Congress to formalise reciprocal extradition arrangements"
Never going to happen. where DO you think Tony is planning to hide when it's all over...
What does банановая республика mean ?
банановая республика = banana republic
ps: "Things can only get better"
банановая республика=banana republic I imagine.
Anonymous 8:16 said...
What does банановая республика mean ?
Banana Republic
GF - monitoring of comments isnt very productive - what is going on?
could it be that two jags and three shags will simply be known as an old lag !
A pity that the latest episode of The Arab-Israeli Conflict is taking up headline news. It makes it easier to ignore things such as this.
I love Banana Republic. They have the best chino skirts.
Speedjunky, traffic cams have already been found to presume guilt in at least one court of law (my friend was the judge) and their evidence tossed out, so don't rule anything out yet.
And I'm with nony 9:26. How many bananas do you need to make a fruit salad?
Pedant said..."The dear Caudillo died in office and of old age".
Not wishing to be pednatic, which one?
I can think of Juan Manuel de Rosas, Juan Facundo Quiroga, Antonio López de Santa Anna,
José Gaspar Rodríguez de Francia,
José Tadeo Monagas,Antonio Guzmán Blanco, Juan Vicente Gómez, Gabriel García Moreno, Rafael Trujillo and Francisco Franco, to name but ten.