Polly is worth every penny of £140,000. I'd say she deserves more. How much does Marina Hyde earn to gush platitudes like "I think your site is great... It is actually entertaining"?
As soon as I read her article yesterday I had exactly the same reaction. The comments page linked to the item has people asking the same question.
This has the potential to be the most fun for we Polly haters since her run in with the Mail over divorce.....
April 23, 2006 at 10:47 AM
Anonymous
said...
Complete transparency of people's earnings would be a gross invasion of privacy and probably would not work entirely where people have overseas assets and earnings.
What got my goat up was not how much some GPs earn (I am sure the vast majority "deserve" (whatever that means) it. What stunned me was how much a tax funded organisation like the Beeb was paying some people. It literally beggars belief. There is simply no justification for a state funded broadcaster to be blowing our money in the way it does. It is just another example of the disconnet in our society.
April 23, 2006 at 10:59 AM
Anonymous
said...
Surely she should also include in her "throwing open the books" her income from the BBC. It must be considerable because she is one of the favoured few journalists who appear on Radio 4 - the other being Trevor Kavanagh from the Daily Mirror. Think having one from the Guardian and one from the Mirror is the BBC's idea of a "balanced view".
But Ms Toynbee equals Patricia Hewitt in being both patronising and sanctimonious, anything she's against I'm for!
April 23, 2006 at 11:05 AM
Anonymous
said...
Hey Anon, only just seen your post. Certainly agree with you about the BBC paying such huge sums to so-called celebs for so little work. Half a million to Jonathan Ross for one 2 hour show! No wonder they want more licence fee money...........
Obviously the BBC knew how contentious this was as they didn't want any of these figures publicised. But this is public money - the BBC is financed by a tax, it isn't voluntary - so "I think we should be told".
April 23, 2006 at 11:10 AM
Anonymous
said...
JJ
I am surprised the BBC issue has not generated more heat and light. God knows why. I'd do any of the presenters' jobs for the minimum wage. In fact i'd do it for free. Of course supply and demand does not really apply where the BBC is concerned.
Much though it pains me to give the BBC any credit for anything approaching fairness / balance, Trevor Kavanagh writes for The Sun, not The Mirror. I would rate him one of the better newpaper political commentators, and there cannnot be a single national which would not wish to have him on its staff.
What got my goat up was not how much some GPs earn
Something can't get one's goat 'up'.
It either gets one's goat, or get one's back up.
Hope this helps.
April 23, 2006 at 11:35 AM
Anonymous
said...
Cranmer
I know I should be grateful for your pedantry but somehow I am not. Despite having nine round for lunch in a moment, I checked the dictionary and you are indeed correct that the expression is "to to get one's goat". I was merely adding emphasis. I shall now go and unhitch my goat and attend to my guests. No wonder no one goes to church anymore.
I was there I was divinely directed to separate the sheep from the goats.
April 23, 2006 at 12:22 PM
Anonymous
said...
And another thing Cranmer. Why should I take lessons in English from someone who has been dead for the best part of 500 years. And I've just googled goat and up and whilst you may consider it incorrect there are others out there using the same expression.
And now back to my guests and my bunting.
April 23, 2006 at 12:26 PM
Anonymous
said...
The Scott Trust which owns the Guardian (and, I think, Smooth FM) is well worth investigating by His Guidoness. Especially for the interesting coincidence that in the past the terms of the trust have been re-written whenever there's been a major change in the taxation of trusts.
The Rowntree trusts, and perhaps also some of the lesser-known ones like the Andrew Wainwright Trust would also repay investigation. There's a whole you-scratch-my-back empire out there among the commentariat.
Polly also serves the purpose of keeping my blood pressure up to suitable pitch, and doubtless has a similar effect on other right thinking people.
Way, way back she was writing on one or other of dismal Gordon's acts of larceny and was moved to describe him as being like a kindly uncle doling out sweets to small children. It made me feel quite ill.
I think Polly would defend anyone's right to get up their goat, as long as the goat was a consenting trade union member and disclosed any money it was paid for the service.
It's a shame that all the sound thinkers here have been dead for so long.
If you are right Guido and she gets £140,000 then, that, by most peoples standards (if not those of the nice Tory Boys who seem to frequent this site)is a very large sum; but its not mega-large. I doubt if it is 54 times the earnings of an average Guardian employee. In any case, to argue that everone should be required to do x, is not to volunteer to do x if others don't (Although maybe she should set an example). And finally, at least she does something for her salary - God knows what that juvenile dolt Jonathan Ross is being paid for.
April 23, 2006 at 1:10 PM
Anonymous
said...
Far more interesting is the fact she sends her kids to private school while writing trade social democratic stuff in the Guardian. Now, I don't care who goes to what school, but if you're saying one thing and doing another, you lose credibility. She's not the only broadsheet soi disant centre-left columnist to do this, not by a long chalk...Time for an audit of the Brown media cheerleaders and where their kids go, perhaps?
Sounds rather like Mary Louisa has fallen prey to the old 'it is not what I do, it is what I say' trick used by uninspired parents, teachers etc everywhere.
La Toynbee's Wikipedia entry is quite illuminating, by the way.
April 23, 2006 at 2:08 PM
Anonymous
said...
Polly Toynbee yet another lefty hypocrite, no surprise there then.
HG - Mary Louise has a great deal of inherited money, and a pal who had an NUJ handbook (with addresses...) has pointed out where she lives - shall we say that if it was turned into bedsits she could make a serious dent in the London housing shortage.
April 23, 2006 at 6:25 PM
Anonymous
said...
while we are on the subject of crap politcil commentatators alice miles of the times is the most sanctimonious weasel ive ever read...adds little to the political debate and is just a nob
I have read 'Ulysses, all three volumes of 'The Gulag Archipelago' and sundry other 'difficult' books, but I have only managed to finish a Peter Riddell column on a handful of occasions.
Agreed on Alice Miles, she is also completely shite.
April 23, 2006 at 10:42 PM
Anonymous
said...
I really don't care if people are overpaid, as long as it's not with tax dollars. Far more important is the issue of people being underpaid. I have read Polly Toynbee, and I suggest that the problem here is really not that she is overpaid to write but that she is underpaid NOT to write. Imagine what someone of talent and brains could do with all those column inches! Perhaps we could take up a collection, or start a Paypal fund to keep her away from the keyboard?
April 24, 2006 at 1:45 AM
Anonymous
said...
Why does anyone pay so much for a journalist on a newspaper ? They are really pretty awful nowadays - The Times is devoid of content, The Guardian is a student rag, and they are so ill-informed.
It is good to know they write for money because I just don't see how newspapers sell unless you want to collect DVDs.
I really don't care if people are overpaid, as long as it's not with tax dollars.
Personally I don't care about tax dollars. Tax Pounds, now thats a worry.
Polly is a typical lefty. (I would be willing to give up half my income only if everyone else does). She uses this cop out for every subject.
There is no reason why she should share this information with us, but it was she that suggested the idea.
April 24, 2006 at 7:33 AM
Anonymous
said...
I wouldn't say she's a typical lefty, but she is an archetype. Champagne socialists, Limo Liberals, etc. No shortage of them; you can find them in SUVs outside posh schools when it's time to pick up the kids. A true socialist would never let the nanny do that!
Still, my primary objection to her is that she neither thinks nor writes particularly well.
I have derived much amusement from calling wealthy lefties 'class traitors'....
April 24, 2006 at 10:16 AM
Anonymous
said...
I wouldn't be at all surprised if for all her cheerleading for Gordon, La Polla uses the services of Mr Jowell or another of his ilk to keep her personal boodle from Gordon's clutches.
Urging us all to pull together for the general good is so much easier when you don't have to pull too much yourself.
Sanctimonious, hypocritical bitch! ay her children develop embarassing body odour.
Croydonian - Yes, I like that one too. Most of them are fundamentally terrified of the people the purport to represent anyway. I'd like to see PT doing an Orwell on a Fife council estate.
April 24, 2006 at 1:20 PM
Anonymous
said...
I emailed her, she told me that I shouldn't target advocates for openess and should be asking Daily Mail writers instead. I pointed out that none of them were calling for my tax return to be released into the public domain.
She's not come back on that one yet.
April 24, 2006 at 3:08 PM
Anonymous
said...
I emailed her, she told me that I shouldn't target advocates for openess and should be asking Daily Mail writers instead. I pointed out that none of them were calling for my tax return to be released into the public domain.
She's not come back on that one yet.
April 24, 2006 at 3:08 PM
Anonymous
said...
HG: Assuming she lives in London ...
She does indeed live in London - in Clapham.
(A couple of minutes on the more intrusive corners of the web shows exactly where.)
Since it is open season on her at the moment, the questions that sprang to mind when she played at slumming it for research for a book and lived in a local authority flat is this: Did she misrepresent her income / status in order to get a council flat, or was the council in cahoots and prioritising her over people who actually needed a house to live in?
43 comments:
Polly is worth every penny of £140,000. I'd say she deserves more. How much does Marina Hyde earn to gush platitudes like "I think your site is great... It is actually entertaining"?
Guido didn't pay her, he blackmailed her.
As soon as I read her article yesterday I had exactly the same reaction. The comments page linked to the item has people asking the same question.
This has the potential to be the most fun for we Polly haters since her run in with the Mail over divorce.....
Complete transparency of people's earnings would be a gross invasion of privacy and probably would not work entirely where people have overseas assets and earnings.
What got my goat up was not how much some GPs earn (I am sure the vast majority "deserve" (whatever that means) it. What stunned me was how much a tax funded organisation like the Beeb was paying some people. It literally beggars belief. There is simply no justification for a state funded broadcaster to be blowing our money in the way it does. It is just another example of the disconnet in our society.
Surely she should also include in her "throwing open the books" her income from the BBC. It must be considerable because she is one of the favoured few journalists who appear on Radio 4 - the other being Trevor Kavanagh from the Daily Mirror. Think having one from the Guardian and one from the Mirror is the BBC's idea of a "balanced view".
But Ms Toynbee equals Patricia Hewitt in being both patronising and sanctimonious, anything she's against I'm for!
Hey Anon, only just seen your post. Certainly agree with you about the BBC paying such huge sums to so-called celebs for so little work. Half a million to Jonathan Ross for one 2 hour show! No wonder they want more licence fee money...........
Obviously the BBC knew how contentious this was as they didn't want any of these figures publicised. But this is public money - the BBC is financed by a tax, it isn't voluntary - so "I think we should be told".
JJ
I am surprised the BBC issue has not generated more heat and light. God knows why. I'd do any of the presenters' jobs for the minimum wage. In fact i'd do it for free. Of course supply and demand does not really apply where the BBC is concerned.
Much though it pains me to give the BBC any credit for anything approaching fairness / balance, Trevor Kavanagh writes for The Sun, not The Mirror. I would rate him one of the better newpaper political commentators, and there cannnot be a single national which would not wish to have him on its staff.
What got my goat up was not how much some GPs earn
Something can't get one's goat 'up'.
It either gets one's goat, or get one's back up.
Hope this helps.
Cranmer
I know I should be grateful for your pedantry but somehow I am not. Despite having nine round for lunch in a moment, I checked the dictionary and you are indeed correct that the expression is "to to get one's goat". I was merely adding emphasis. I shall now go and unhitch my goat and attend to my guests. No wonder no one goes to church anymore.
cranma, are you sure?
It is either gets one's goat or get up one's goat
come on, dont be sheepish!
There is simply no justification for a state funded (i.e extortion funded) broadcaster.
No need to add anyything else.
It is measure of how craven we are polotically that we have submitted to this unfair impost.
Pope's Underpants,
I have been in Church.
I was there I was divinely directed to separate the sheep from the goats.
And another thing Cranmer. Why should I take lessons in English from someone who has been dead for the best part of 500 years. And I've just googled goat and up and whilst you may consider it incorrect there are others out there using the same expression.
And now back to my guests and my bunting.
The Scott Trust which owns the Guardian (and, I think, Smooth FM) is well worth investigating by His Guidoness. Especially for the interesting coincidence that in the past the terms of the trust have been re-written whenever there's been a major change in the taxation of trusts.
The Rowntree trusts, and perhaps also some of the lesser-known ones like the Andrew Wainwright Trust would also repay investigation. There's a whole you-scratch-my-back empire out there among the commentariat.
Anon,
If you've got nothing better to do than to google 'goat' and 'up', you have profound spiritual needs.
I have indeed been dead 'for the best part of 500 years', but i) it was the golden age of the English language and ii) so has Guido.
Actually old man, I've been dead 400 years.
Polly also serves the purpose of keeping my blood pressure up to suitable pitch, and doubtless has a similar effect on other right thinking people.
Way, way back she was writing on one or other of dismal Gordon's acts of larceny and was moved to describe him as being like a kindly uncle doling out sweets to small children. It made me feel quite ill.
I think Polly would defend anyone's right to get up their goat, as long as the goat was a consenting trade union member and disclosed any money it was paid for the service.
It's a shame that all the sound thinkers here have been dead for so long.
If you are right Guido and she gets £140,000 then, that, by most peoples standards (if not those of the nice Tory Boys who seem to frequent this site)is a very large sum; but its not mega-large. I doubt if it is 54 times the earnings of an average Guardian employee. In any case, to argue that everone should be required to do x, is not to volunteer to do x if others don't (Although maybe she should set an example). And finally, at least she does something for her salary - God knows what that juvenile dolt Jonathan Ross is being paid for.
Far more interesting is the fact she sends her kids to private school while writing trade social democratic stuff in the Guardian. Now, I don't care who goes to what school, but if you're saying one thing and doing another, you lose credibility. She's not the only broadsheet soi disant centre-left columnist to do this, not by a long chalk...Time for an audit of the Brown media cheerleaders and where their kids go, perhaps?
Sounds rather like Mary Louisa has fallen prey to the old 'it is not what I do, it is what I say' trick used by uninspired parents, teachers etc everywhere.
La Toynbee's Wikipedia entry is quite illuminating, by the way.
Polly Toynbee yet another lefty hypocrite, no surprise there then.
Far more interesting is the fact she sends her kids to private school...
Kids?
Is she a goat as well then?
I didn't know it was on. I was working on a sermon, communing with the Holy Goat.
I shall now indulge.
Thank you.
Nice the way the 'online weight loss' [?]
ad' obscures the UNICEF ad' in Firefox.
HG - Mary Louise has a great deal of inherited money, and a pal who had an NUJ handbook (with addresses...) has pointed out where she lives - shall we say that if it was turned into bedsits she could make a serious dent in the London housing shortage.
while we are on the subject of crap politcil commentatators alice miles of the times is the most sanctimonious weasel ive ever read...adds little to the political debate and is just a nob
I have read 'Ulysses, all three volumes of 'The Gulag Archipelago' and sundry other 'difficult' books, but I have only managed to finish a Peter Riddell column on a handful of occasions.
Agreed on Alice Miles, she is also completely shite.
I really don't care if people are overpaid, as long as it's not with tax dollars. Far more important is the issue of people being underpaid. I have read Polly Toynbee, and I suggest that the problem here is really not that she is overpaid to write but that she is underpaid NOT to write. Imagine what someone of talent and brains could do with all those column inches! Perhaps we could take up a collection, or start a Paypal fund to keep her away from the keyboard?
Why does anyone pay so much for a journalist on a newspaper ? They are really pretty awful nowadays - The Times is devoid of content, The Guardian is a student rag, and they are so ill-informed.
It is good to know they write for money because I just don't see how newspapers sell unless you want to collect DVDs.
I really don't care if people are overpaid, as long as it's not with tax dollars.
Personally I don't care about tax dollars. Tax Pounds, now thats a worry.
Polly is a typical lefty. (I would be willing to give up half my income only if everyone else does). She uses this cop out for every subject.
There is no reason why she should share this information with us, but it was she that suggested the idea.
I wouldn't say she's a typical lefty, but she is an archetype. Champagne socialists, Limo Liberals, etc. No shortage of them; you can find them in SUVs outside posh schools when it's time to pick up the kids. A true socialist would never let the nanny do that!
Still, my primary objection to her is that she neither thinks nor writes particularly well.
I have derived much amusement from calling wealthy lefties 'class traitors'....
I wouldn't be at all surprised if for all her cheerleading for Gordon, La Polla uses the services of Mr Jowell or another of his ilk to keep her personal boodle from Gordon's clutches.
Urging us all to pull together for the general good is so much easier when you don't have to pull too much yourself.
Sanctimonious, hypocritical bitch! ay her children develop embarassing body odour.
RM
Croydonian - Yes, I like that one too. Most of them are fundamentally terrified of the people the purport to represent anyway. I'd like to see PT doing an Orwell on a Fife council estate.
I emailed her, she told me that I shouldn't target advocates for openess and should be asking Daily Mail writers instead. I pointed out that none of them were calling for my tax return to be released into the public domain.
She's not come back on that one yet.
I emailed her, she told me that I shouldn't target advocates for openess and should be asking Daily Mail writers instead. I pointed out that none of them were calling for my tax return to be released into the public domain.
She's not come back on that one yet.
HG: Assuming she lives in London ...
She does indeed live in London - in Clapham.
(A couple of minutes on the more intrusive corners of the web shows exactly where.)
Since it is open season on her at the moment, the questions that sprang to mind when she played at slumming it for research for a book and lived in a local authority flat is this: Did she misrepresent her income / status in order to get a council flat, or was the council in cahoots and prioritising her over people who actually needed a house to live in?
Guess what, she's dropped the disclosure idea like a hot brick - nothing following it up in her column today. Fancy....